Opinion: The 49ers Overpaid Jimmy Garopollo Big Time

The San Francisco 49ers signed quarterback Jimmy Garopollo to a 5 year, $137 million dollar contract on Thursday. $48 million of it is guaranteed. Garopollo came over from the Patriots in a trade last season and led the 49ers to a 5-0 record in the games he started.

Look, I get it. I know you have to pay quarterbacks today, especially upper echelon quarterbacks but the 49ers badly overpaid for Garopollo.

I get it. Garopollo is 7-0 as a starter, has plus arm strength and his intangibles are off the charts but he has only started seven games. Seven flippin games! You pay a quarterback $27.5 million per season on production and reputation, not potential.

Could Garopollo be the next great quarterback in the NFL? Sure, there is no doubt that he has the potential to be an elite starter in the NFL for a long time. So offer him a bridge contract for four years at $60-$70 million and see how he does. If Garopollo out perform that contract, then give him a longer, more lucrative extension.

Quarterback is the most important position in sports. It is also the most difficult position in sports to evaluate. You either have “that guy” or you don’t. I understand paying him if you think your quarterback is that guy but the 49ers over extended themselves on this one.

It is obvious that John Lynch and Kyle Shanahan felt that they were going to overpay for a guy like Kirk Cousins so why not overpay Garopollo. You already know what he can do. I get that logic but again, they didn’t need to overpay him to keep him in the fold. No team in the open market was going to give Garopollo that kind of money.

Successful quarterbacks have good pieces around them. For every Tom Brady, there are ten to fifteen quarterbacks in the NFL that are good enough to start but are not elite because they are overpaid and the pieces around them aren’t good enough to help them. Garopollo is in that type of situation right now.

It remains to be seen if Garopollo is good enough long term to take this organization to the next level. A 7-0 record as a starter is impressive but it is only a small sample. Let’s see what he does a full time starter and see if he worth being the highest paid player in the league.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *